Skip to main content
Chemistry LibreTexts

Appendix 2: Peer and Self-Assessment of Laboratory Proposal

The information requested is CONFIDENTIAL and will not be shared with other members of the class.  It will be used to assess how well student assessment of the work on the proposal portion of the laboratory projects agrees with my own.  These evaluations must be turned in at the same time that your proposal is due.

Please evaluate everyone’s contribution to the proposal, including your own, for each of the following criteria.  Provide a mark out of 10 for each category.

Evaluation Scale:

10-9     - Outstanding contribution

8-7       - Very good contribution

6-5       - Good contribution

4-3       - Fairly satisfactory contribution

2-1       - Unsatisfactory contribution

0          - No or virtually no contribution

Criteria:

A – Gathering literature

B – Reading and evaluating the literature

C – Helping to develop and write the proposal

D – Attendance at meetings to develop and write the proposal

E – Undertaking a fair share of the work

F – Ability to arrive at consensus/overcome difficulties

G – Ability to facilitate the group’s efforts

 

Your name __________________________________________________

Name of person you are evaluating ___________________________________________

Category         Score               Comments

A

 

B

 

C

 

D

 

E

 

F

 

G

 

What percent of the total effort that went into writing the proposal did this individual contribute (The total for all of your group members must be 100%)?

 

 

Any additional comments you wish to make about this individual’s contribution to the project: