2.3: Structure and Stability of Benzene
After completing this section, you should be able to
- compare the reactivity of a typical alkene with that of benzene.
- Use the heat of hydrogenation data to show that benzene is more stable than might be expected for “cyclohexatriene.”
- state the length of the carbon-carbon bonds in benzene, and compare this length with those of bonds found in other hydrocarbons.
- describe the geometry of the benzene molecule.
- describe the structure of benzene in terms of resonance.
- describe the structure of benzene in terms of molecular orbital theory.
- draw a molecular orbital diagram for benzene.
Make certain that you can define, and use in context, the key term below.
- degenerate
Note that the figure showing the molecular orbitals of benzene has two bonding ( ψ 2 and ψ 3 ) and two anti-bonding ( ψ 4 * and ψ 5 *) orbital pairs at the same energy levels. Orbitals with the same energy are described as degenerate orbitals.
Structure of Benzene
When benzene (C 6 H 6 ) was first discovered its low hydrogen to carbon ratio (1:1) led chemists to believe it contained double or triple bonds. Since double and triple bonds rapidly add bromine (Br 2 ), this reaction was applied to benzene. Surprisingly, benzene was entirely unreactive toward bromine. In addition, if benzene is forced to react with bromine through the addition of a catalyst, it undergoes substitution reactions rather than the addition reactions that are typical of alkenes. These experiments suggested that the six-carbon benzene core is unusually stable for chemical reactions.
The conceptual contradiction presented by a high degree of unsaturation (low H:C ratio) and high chemical stability for benzene and related compounds remained an unsolved puzzle for many years. Eventually, the presently accepted structure of benzene as a hexagonal, planar ring of carbons with alternating single and double bonds was adopted, and the exceptional chemical stability of this system was attributed to special resonance stabilization of the conjugated cyclic triene. No single structure provides an accurate representation of benzene as it is a combination of two structurally and energetically equivalent resonance forms representing the continuous cyclic conjugation of the double bonds. In the past, the benzene resonance hybrid was represented by a hexagon with a circle in the center to represent the benzene's pi-electron delocalization. This method has largely been abandoned because it does not show the pi electrons contained in benzene. Currently, the structure of benzene is usually represented by drawing one resonance form with the understanding that it does not completely represent the true structure of benzene.
The six-membered ring in benzene is a perfect hexagon with all carbon-carbon bonds having an identical length of 139 pm 1 . The 139 pm bond length is roughly in between those of a C=C double bond (134 pm) and a C-C single (154 pm) which agrees with the benzene ring being a resonance hybrid made up of 1.5 C-C bonds. Each carbon in the benzene ring is sp 2 hybridized which makes all the C-C-C and H-C-C bond angles in benzene 120 o and makes the overall molecule planar.
The High Stability of Benzene
In previous polyalkene, examples the electron delocalization described by resonance enhanced the stability of the molecule. However, benzene's stability goes beyond this. Evidence for the enhanced thermodynamic stability of benzene was obtained from measurements of the heat released when double bonds in a six-carbon ring are hydrogenated (hydrogen is added catalytically) to give cyclohexane as a common product. In the following diagram cyclohexane represents a low-energy reference point. The addition of hydrogen to cyclohexene produces cyclohexane and releases heat amounting to 118 kJ/mol. If we take this value to represent the energy cost of introducing one double bond into a six-carbon ring, we would expect a 1,3-cyclohexadiene to release 236 kJ/mol on complete hydrogenation, but the actual value is 230 kJ/mol, a bit less than twice that for cyclohexene because conjugated dienes are more stable than isolated dienes.
Carrying the process one step further, we might expect \(ΔH^{°}_{\text{hydrog}}\) for “cyclohexatriene” (benzene) to be a bit less than 3 × 118 = 354 kJ/mol, or three times the cyclohexene value. The actual value, however, is –206 kJ/mol, some 148 kJ/mol (35.4 kcal/mol) less than expected. Because of this difference in actual and expected energy released during hydrogenation, benzene must have 148 kJ/mol less energy to begin with. In other words, benzene is more stable than expected by 148 kJ/mol.
Fur
These heats of hydrogenation would reflect the relative thermodynamic stability of the compounds. In practice, 1,3-cyclohexadiene is slightly more stable than expected, by about 2 kcal, presumably due to conjugation of the double bonds. Benzene, however, is an extraordinary 36 kcal/mole more stable than expected . This sort of stability enhancement is called aromaticity and molecules with aromaticity are called aromatic compounds. Benzene is the most common aromatic compound but there are many others. Aromatic stabilization explains benzene's lack of reactivity compared to typical alkenes.
Atomic Orbitals of Benzene
Also, each of benzene's six carbon atoms are sp 2 hybridized and have an unhybrized p orbital perpendicular to plane of the ring. Because each of the six carbon atoms and their corresponding p orbitals are equivalent, it is impossible for them to only overlap with one adjacent p orbital to create three defined double bonds. Instead each p orbital overlaps equally with both adjacent orbitals creating a cyclic overlap involving all six p orbitals. This allows the p orbitals to be delocalized in molecular orbitals that extend all the way around the ring allowing for more overlap than would be obtained from the linear 1,3,5-hexatriene equivalent.
For this to happen, of course, the ring must be planar – otherwise the p orbitals couldn’t overlap properly and benzene is known to be a flat molecule. An electrostatic potential map of benzene, shown below, shows that the pi electrons are evenly distributed around the ring and that every carbon equivalent.
The Molecular Orbitals of Benzene
A molecular orbital description of benzene provides a more satisfying and more general treatment of "aromaticity". We know that benzene has a planar hexagonal structure in which all the carbon atoms are sp 2 hybridized, and all the carbon-carbon bonds are equal in length. As shown below, the remaining cyclic array of six p-orbitals ( one on each carbon) overlap to generate six molecular orbitals, three bonding and three antibonding. The plus and minus signs shown in the diagram do not represent electrostatic charge, but refer to phase signs in the equations that describe these orbitals (in the diagram the phases are also color coded). The three low-energy molecular orbitals, denoted ψ 1 , ψ 2 , and ψ 3 , are bonding combinations, and the three high-energy orbitals are antibonding.
When the phases correspond, the orbitals overlap to generate a common region of like phase, with those orbitals having the greatest overlap (e.g. ψ 1 ) being the lowest in energy. The remaining carbon valence electrons then occupy these molecular orbitals in pairs, resulting in a fully occupied (6 electrons) set of bonding molecular orbitals. It is this completely filled set of bonding orbitals, or closed shell , that gives the benzene ring its thermodynamic and chemical stability, just as a filled valence shell octet confers stability on the inert gases.
Note that the two bonding orbitals ψ 2 and ψ 3 have the same energy, as do the two antibonding orbitals ψ 4 * and ψ 5 * . Such orbitals with the same energy are said to be degenerate . Note also that the two orbitals ψ 3 and ψ 4 * have nodes passing through ring carbon atoms, thereby leaving no \(\pi\) electron density on these carbons. The six p electrons of benzene occupy the three bonding molecular orbitals and are delocalized over the entire conjugated system, leading to the observed 150 kJ/mol stabilization of benzene.
To better see source of the stabilizing aromaticity effect created by the cyclic p orbitals of benzene, the molecular orbitals of 1,3,5-hexatriene must be investigated. The molecule 1,3,5-hexatriene contains six p orbitals which all overlap but in a linear fashion. As with benzene, this overlap creates 3 stabilized bonding molecular which are completely filled with six p electron. As expected, the conjugation creates a marked increase of stability in 1,3,5-hexatriene but not as much as in benzene.
The main difference in stability can be seen when comparing the lowest energy molecular orbital of 1,3,5-hexatriene and benzene: pi 1 . In pi 1 molecular orbital of 1,3,5-hexatriene there are 5 stabilizing bonding interactions where there are 6 stabilizing bonding interactions in the pi 1 of benzene. The sixth bonding interaction is made possible by benzene's p orbitals being in a ring. Because benzene's pi 1 molecular orbital has more stabilizing bonding interactions it is lower in energy than the pi 1 molecular orbital of 1,3,5-hexatriene. This gives benzene the additional aromatic stability not seen in the acyclic 1,3,5-hexatriene.
Exercises
The molecule, pyridine, is planar with bond angles of 120 o . Pyridine has many other characteristics similar to benzene. Draw a diagram showing the p orbitals in pyridine and use it to explain its similarity to benzene.
- Answer
-
The nitrogen and each carbon in the pyridine ring is sp 2 hybridized. In the bonding picture for pyridine, the nitrogen is sp 2 -hybridized, with two of the three sp 2 orbitals forming sigma overlaps with the sp 2 orbitals of neighboring carbon atoms, and the third nitrogen sp 2 orbital containing the lone pair electrons. The unhybridized p orbital contains a single electron, which is part of the 6 pi-electron system delocalized around the ring. Pyridine is most likely aromatic which gives it its planar shape and 120 o bond angles.
The molecule shown, p -methylpyridine, has similar properties to benzene (flat, 120° bond angles). Draw the pi-orbitals for this compound.
- Answer
-
References
https://royalsocietypublishing.org/d...rspa.1964.0092 "A crystallographic study of solid benzene by neutron diffraction" G.E. Bacon, N. A. Curry, and S.A. Wilson, 1964