Skip to main content
Chemistry LibreTexts

3.2.4: Ligand Close Packing

  • Page ID
    222357
  • Introduction

    Ligand Close Packing (LCP) theory is complimentary to VSEPR, except that LCP focuses on repulsions between pendant atoms ("outer" atoms that are not directly bonded to one another), rather than focusing on the chemical environment around the central atom in a molecule. Both LCP and the VSEPR models were developed by Robert Gillespie.

    The LCP model assumes that ligands (or pendant atoms) "pack" as close as possible around a central atom. A given ligand will have a specific atomic raddii when bound to a central atom. The distance between two ligands around the same central atom is simply the sum of atomic radii of the pendant atoms. Therefore for a specific set of ligands around a sepcific central atom, the ligand-ligand distances are constant despite the coordination number or bond angles. In other words, for a series of similar molecules with the same central atom, while bond angles and bond distances of pendant atoms may change, the distances between two pendant atoms remain the same.

    Ligand Close Packing Theory

    According to LCP, distances between two pendant atoms are similar...

    • even when steric number changes
    • even when bond angles change
    • Reason: pendant atoms "pack" around the central atom.

    Ligand Close Packing and Bond Distances

    If distance between non-bonded atoms remains constant even while bond angles change, then the bond length between the pendant and central atom must change to accommodate. For example, \(\ce{PF4+}\) and \(\ce{PF3O}\) have almost identical \(\ce{F - F}\) distances of 238 and 237 pm, respectively. As expected from VSEPR, the \(\ce{F - P - F}\) bond angle in \(\ce{PF4+}\) is 109.5°. The \(\ce{F - P - F}\) bond angle in \(\ce{PF3O}\) (101.1°) is smaller due to the increased repulsion of the oxygen double bond. Therefore the P-F bond lengths must be different. In fact, the P-F bond distances are 145.7 pm in \(\ce{PF4+}\) and 154 pm in \(\ce{PF3O}\).

    Screen Shot 2020-11-23 at 9.42.04 PM.png
    Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\): The molecular structures of \(\ce{PF4+}\) and \(\ce{PF3O}\). The distances between neighboring F atoms are similar in the two molecules, while bond lengths and angels differ. The \(\ce{PF4+}\) ion has a \(\ce{P - F}\) bond length of 145.7 pm, a \(\ce{F - P - F}\) bond angle of 109.5°, and a distance of 238 pm between neighboring F atoms. The \(\ce{PF3O}\) molecule has a \(\ce{P - F}\) bond length of 154 pm, a \(\ce{F - P - F}\) bond angle of 101.1°, and a distance of 237 pm between neighboring F atoms. (CC-BY-NC-SA; Kathryn Haas)

    The relationship between bond angles, bond lengths, and close-packing distance is described by right angle trigonometry (recall SOA-CAH-TOA). In a right triangle, the hypotenuse is the longet side, opposite of the right angle. For either of the other two angles in the triangle, the angle (\(\theta\)) and lengths of the sides (opposite and adjacent to \(\theta\)) are related by the trigometric functions shown in Figure \(\PageIndex{2}\).

    Screen Shot 2020-06-25 at 3.58.37 PM.png
    Figure \(\PageIndex{2}\): Visual depiction of SOA-CAH-TOA. (CC-BY-NC-SA; Kathryn Haas)

    In the case of a molecule, we can apply right angle trigonometry by imagining that the bond angle is divided into two right angles, as illustrated in Figure \(\PageIndex{2}\). The hypotenuse of the triangles is the bond length, the opposite side is one half of the close-packing distance, and \(\theta\) is one half the bond angle.

    Screen Shot 2020-06-25 at 4.03.35 PM.png
    Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\): Illustration of how right angle trigonometry can be applied to determine bond angle, bond length, or distance between neighboring atoms: any bond angle can be divided into two right angles where the bond length is the hypotenuse, the distance between neighbors is twice the opposite side, and the bond angle is twice \(\theta\). (CC-BY-NC-SA; Kathryn Haas)

    Exercise \(\PageIndex{1}\)

    The distance between F atoms is 212 pm in both \(\ce{NF4+}\) and \(\ce{NF3}\). The bond angles are 109.5° and 102.3°, respectively. What are the expected \(\ce{N - F}\) bond lengths?

    Answer

    Screen Shot 2020-06-25 at 4.27.17 PM.png

    The actual measured bond lengths are 130 pm for \(\ce{NF4+}\) and 136.5 pm for \(\ce{NF3}\).

    Acknowledgment

    • Was this article helpful?